Logo etsi

ETSI's Bug Tracker
Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap | Monitor project
  
Notice: information submitted on the ETSI issue Tracker may be incorporated in ETSI publication(s) and therefore subject to the ETSI IPR policy.

View Issue Details [ Jump to Notes ] [ Issue History ] [ Print ]
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0007423Part-1 Metamodel[TDL] Technicalpublic09-03-2016 13:5909-05-2016 15:40
ReporterPhilip Makedonski 
Assigned ToPhilip Makedonski 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
StatusresolvedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product Version[TDL] Part-1 V1.2.1 
Target Version[TDL] Part-1 V1.3.1Fixed in Version[TDL] Part-1 V1.3.1 
Summary0007423: Comments and Annotations shall be ordered
DescriptionCurrently, comments and annotations attached to elements are not ordered. For various representations (textual, tabular) these shall be ordered to ensure consistent representation. Change the modifiers in the meta-model accordingly.
TagsNo tags attached.
Attached Filespdf file icon MultiCommentShape.pdf [^] (20,376 bytes) 09-03-2016 14:39

- Relationships

-  Notes
(0013882)
Philip Makedonski (manager)
09-03-2016 14:00

 As proposed.
(0013884)
Gusztáv Adamis (manager)
09-03-2016 14:18

 Questions: what can be a use case in which the order of the comments are relevant?
As the proposal says, in some notations it may be important but in some other notation (like GR) it can be hard to solve.
Is this ordering REALLY required?
(0013885)
Philip Makedonski (manager)
09-03-2016 14:30

 The ordering is a property of the meta-model element. A notation may or may not make use of this property. A graphical notation may display comments as bubbles without being able to modify their order (which can still be modified in e.g. associated tree editor or using property view).

If the ordering is not provided by the meta-model then textual, tabular, or tree-based notations have no means of ensuring that the elements are stored and presented in a particular order so two related comments that are represented on two lines (or even in separate strings on the same line) in a textual notation may appear out of order the next time the document is opened.

If it is required to be solved in a graphical notation, then an alternative representation can be proposed where all comments are grouped in the same bubble with one compartment per comment (which will be a more concise representation), e.g.:

--------------
| Comments |
--------------
| comment1 |
--------------___
| comment2 | \
-------------- \
| ... | \
-------------- -------- #ELEMENT
(0013886)
Philip Makedonski (manager)
09-03-2016 14:38

 OK my picture got damaged for some reason, see attachment.
(0013887)
Philip Makedonski (manager)
09-03-2016 14:39

 Same applies to Annotations
(0013957)
Philip Makedonski (manager)
09-05-2016 15:40

 Implemented as proposed

- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
09-03-2016 13:59 Philip Makedonski New Issue
09-03-2016 13:59 Philip Makedonski Status new => assigned
09-03-2016 13:59 Philip Makedonski Assigned To => Philip Makedonski
09-03-2016 14:00 Philip Makedonski Note Added: 0013882
09-03-2016 14:00 Philip Makedonski Status assigned => resolved
09-03-2016 14:00 Philip Makedonski Fixed in Version => [TDL] Part-1 V1.3.1
09-03-2016 14:00 Philip Makedonski Resolution open => fixed
09-03-2016 14:18 Gusztáv Adamis Note Added: 0013884
09-03-2016 14:18 Gusztáv Adamis Status resolved => feedback
09-03-2016 14:18 Gusztáv Adamis Resolution fixed => reopened
09-03-2016 14:30 Philip Makedonski Note Added: 0013885
09-03-2016 14:30 Philip Makedonski Status feedback => assigned
09-03-2016 14:38 Philip Makedonski Note Added: 0013886
09-03-2016 14:39 Philip Makedonski File Added: MultiCommentShape.pdf
09-03-2016 14:39 Philip Makedonski Note Added: 0013887
09-05-2016 15:40 Philip Makedonski Note Added: 0013957
09-05-2016 15:40 Philip Makedonski Status assigned => resolved
09-05-2016 15:40 Philip Makedonski Resolution reopened => fixed

MantisBT 1.2.14 [^]
Copyright © 2000 - 2024 MantisBT Team
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker