Skip to content
  • Matt Caswell's avatar
    Deprecate RAND_pseudo_bytes · 302d38e3
    Matt Caswell authored
    
    
    The justification for RAND_pseudo_bytes is somewhat dubious, and the reality
    is that it is frequently being misused. RAND_bytes and RAND_pseudo_bytes in
    the default implementation both end up calling ssleay_rand_bytes. Both may
    return -1 in an error condition. If there is insufficient entropy then
    both will return 0, but RAND_bytes will additionally add an error to the
    error queue. They both return 1 on success.
    Therefore the fundamental difference between the two is that one will add an
    error to the error queue with insufficient entory whilst the other will not.
    Frequently there are constructions of this form:
    
    if(RAND_pseudo_bytes(...) <= 1)
    	goto err;
    
    In the above form insufficient entropy is treated as an error anyway, so
    RAND_bytes is probably the better form to use.
    
    This form is also seen:
    if(!RAND_pseudo_bytes(...))
    	goto err;
    
    This is technically not correct at all since a -1 return value is
    incorrectly handled - but this form will also treat insufficient entropy as
    an error.
    
    Within libssl it is required that you have correctly seeded your entropy
    pool and so there seems little benefit in using RAND_pseudo_bytes.
    Similarly in libcrypto many operations also require a correctly seeded
    entropy pool and so in most interesting cases you would be better off
    using RAND_bytes anyway. There is a significant risk of RAND_pseudo_bytes
    being incorrectly used in scenarios where security can be compromised by
    insufficient entropy.
    
    If you are not using the default implementation, then most engines use the
    same function to implement RAND_bytes and RAND_pseudo_bytes in any case.
    
    Given its misuse, limited benefit, and potential to compromise security,
    RAND_pseudo_bytes has been deprecated.
    
    Reviewed-by: default avatarRichard Levitte <levitte@openssl.org>
    302d38e3
To find the state of this project's repository at the time of any of these versions, check out the tags.