ETSI's Bug Tracker - SOL001 - TOSCA-based NFV descriptors spec
View Issue Details
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0008137SOL001 - TOSCA-based NFV descriptors spec[NFV Specifications] Bugpublic11-11-2022 05:5326-07-2023 05:38
ReporterSujeet Banerjee 
Assigned Tolishi 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
StatusresolvedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product Version4.2.1 
Target VersionFixed in VersionSOL001ed451 v4.4.4 
Summary0008137: [4.3.1] [Section 6.8.1.2] Incorrect ABNF Grammar Specified for "Vnfm_info"
DescriptionThis is incorrect in the specified Grammar:
-----------
value = any_etsi_nfv_compliant_product| product_specific

any_etsi_nfv_compliant_product = "etsivnfm" SEP "version"

version = "v" version_identifier

version_identifier = 1*2DIGIT DOT 1*2DIGIT DOT 1*2DIGIT
; the version identifier is encoded as a sequence of items of 1 or 2 digits separated by dots
representing the 3 fields (major, technical and editorial) of the version of an ETSI deliverable.

product_specific = enterprise_number SEP product_specific_string

enterprise_number = 1*DIGIT

product_specific_string = *(ALPHA / DIGIT / "-" / ".")

SEP = ":"

DOT = "."
-----------

THE INCORRECT RULE SPECIFIED, THAT DOES NOT MATCH THE EXAMPLE:

>>> any_etsi_nfv_compliant_product = "etsivnfm" SEP "version"

THE LITERAL "version" SPECIFIED IS INCORRECT. IN FACT, IT'S NOT A LITERAL, RATHER IT'S NON-TERMINAL <version>
Steps To Reproduce
Additional InformationTHE CORRECT RULE WOULD BE:

>>> any_etsi_nfv_compliant_product = "etsivnfm" SEP version

(i.e. version WITHOUT THE QUOTES)

TagsNo tags attached.
Relationships
has duplicate 0008138resolved lishi [4.3.1] [Section 6.8.1.2] Incorrect ABNF Grammar Specified for "Vnfm_info" 
has duplicate 0008150resolved Yuya Kuno Incorrect ABNF Grammar specified for vnfm_info 
Attached Filesdocx NFVSOL(23)000240_SOL001ed451_correct_ABNF_Grammar_.docx (65,568) 26-07-2023 05:35
http://oldforge.etsi.org/mantis/file_download.php?file_id=4118&type=bug
Issue History
Date ModifiedUsernameFieldChange
11-11-2022 05:53Sujeet BanerjeeNew Issue
06-12-2022 09:56lishiNote Added: 0016332
06-12-2022 09:56lishiAssigned To => lishi
06-12-2022 09:56lishiStatusnew => confirmed
15-12-2022 09:18Sujeet BanerjeeIssue cloned: 0008163
26-07-2023 05:35Yuya KunoFile Added: NFVSOL(23)000240_SOL001ed451_correct_ABNF_Grammar_.docx
26-07-2023 05:35Yuya KunoNote Added: 0016499
26-07-2023 05:38Yuya KunoNote Added: 0016500
26-07-2023 05:38Yuya KunoStatusconfirmed => resolved
26-07-2023 05:38Yuya KunoResolutionopen => fixed
26-07-2023 05:38Yuya KunoFixed in Version => SOL001ed451 v4.4.4
26-07-2023 05:38Yuya KunoNote Added: 0016501
07-05-2024 07:30Yuya KunoRelationship addedhas duplicate 0008138
07-05-2024 07:31Yuya KunoRelationship addedhas duplicate 0008150

Notes
(0016332)
lishi   
06-12-2022 09:56   
Thanks. It will be fixed in the next version.
(0016499)
Yuya Kuno   
26-07-2023 05:35   
This issue was addressed by NFVSOL(23)000240.
(0016500)
Yuya Kuno   
26-07-2023 05:38   
This issues was addressed by NFVSOL(23)000240.
(0016501)
Yuya Kuno   
26-07-2023 05:38   
This issues was addressed by NFVSOL(23)000240.