ETSI's Bug Tracker - SOL001 - TOSCA-based NFV descriptors spec
View Issue Details
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0008117SOL001 - TOSCA-based NFV descriptors spec[NFV Specifications] Feature Gappublic12-09-2022 08:3207-05-2024 07:15
ReporterSujeet Banerjee 
Assigned Tolishi 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
StatusresolvedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product Version4.2.1 
Target VersionFixed in Version 
Summary0008117: [4.3.1] [Section A.18] INCORRECT REFERENCES in the Diagram in NFV-SOL 001v4.3.1 - GS - TOSCA-based NFV descriptors spec.pdf
DescriptionSpec Link: https://docbox.etsi.org/isg/nfv/open/Publications_pdf/Specs-Reports/NFV-SOL%20001v4.3.1%20-%20GS%20-%20TOSCA-based%20NFV%20descriptors%20spec.pdf [^]

Section A.18
-----------
In the figure "Figure A.18-1: Containerized VNF example", the vertical line labeled "Internal Virtual Link" is INCORRECTLY shown as connected to vdu2Cp1 and vdu1Cp1.

HOWEVER, as per the VNFD descriptor, the "Internal Virtual Link" (InternalVl) should be shown to be connected to "vdu2Cp2" and "vdu1Cp2".

Steps To Reproduce
Additional Information
TagsNo tags attached.
Relationships
Attached Files
Issue History
Date ModifiedUsernameFieldChange
12-09-2022 08:32Sujeet BanerjeeNew Issue
12-09-2022 08:35Sujeet BanerjeeNote Added: 0016239
15-09-2022 09:45Sujeet BanerjeeNote Edited: 0016239bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=16239#r589
10-10-2022 09:44lishiNote Added: 0016253
10-10-2022 10:01Sujeet BanerjeeNote Added: 0016254
01-11-2022 01:07lishiAssigned To => lishi
01-11-2022 01:07lishiStatusnew => resolved
01-11-2022 01:07lishiResolutionopen => fixed
11-11-2022 04:49Sujeet BanerjeeNote Added: 0016303
11-11-2022 04:49Sujeet BanerjeeStatusresolved => feedback
11-11-2022 04:49Sujeet BanerjeeResolutionfixed => reopened
01-12-2022 06:58lishiNote Added: 0016316
15-12-2022 09:18Sujeet BanerjeeIssue cloned: 0008164
11-10-2023 08:09Sujeet BanerjeeNote Added: 0016529
11-10-2023 08:09Sujeet BanerjeeStatusfeedback => assigned
07-05-2024 07:15Yuya KunoNote Added: 0016630
07-05-2024 07:15Yuya KunoStatusassigned => resolved
07-05-2024 07:15Yuya KunoResolutionreopened => fixed

Notes
(0016239)
Sujeet Banerjee   
12-09-2022 08:35   
(edited on: 15-09-2022 09:45)
The Category of this ticket should not be "[NFV Specifications] Feature Gap". I am unable to edit/change it to "Bug"
(0016253)
lishi   
10-10-2022 09:44   
Please see NFVSOL(22)000449 to resolve this issue.
(0016254)
Sujeet Banerjee   
10-10-2022 10:01   
The diagram needs to be fixed in the example referred ("Figure A.18-1: Containerized VNF example"). And then the ticket may be resolved.
(0016303)
Sujeet Banerjee   
11-11-2022 04:49   
Not sure why is this ticket marked "FIXED", I see the referred document-Figure is still not fixed.

Also, can you please provide the link to: NFVSOL(22)000449?
(0016316)
lishi   
01-12-2022 06:58   
https://docbox.etsi.org/ISG/NFV/SOL/05-CONTRIBUTIONS/2022//NFVSOL(22)000449_SOL001ed441_multiple_corrections.docx [^]
(0016529)
Sujeet Banerjee   
11-10-2023 08:09   
The Diagram is correct as it appears in SOL001 4.4.1. The issue may be closed.
(0016630)
Yuya Kuno   
07-05-2024 07:15   
NFVSOL(22)000449