ETSI's Bug Tracker - SOL005 - Os-Ma-nfvo APIs
View Issue Details
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0008008SOL005 - Os-Ma-nfvo APIs[NFV Specifications] Bugpublic25-02-2021 08:3431-01-2022 14:12
Reporteryaoyudie 
Assigned ToVlademir Brusse 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
StatusclosedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product VersionSOL005ed241 v2.4.1 
Target VersionFixed in VersionSOL005ed241 v2.4.1 
Summary0008008: Conflict definition with disk/Container format with specification and vnfd yaml file
Descriptionthe definition of disk and container format is conflicted when OpenStack is using lower letters but in the specification uppercase is used.
While checking the specification, it said we should refer to the OpenStack file

Also in the VNFD type files , which downloaded from the website offered in OpenStack official document, the uppercase isn’t supported.
Steps To Reproduce
Additional InformationOpenStack file:
https://docs.openstack.org/glance/pike/user/formats.html [^]
specification:
gs_NFV-SOL003v020401p.pdf and gs_NFV-SOL003v020601p.pdf
VNFD type file: https://forge.etsi.org/rep/nfv/SOL001/raw/v2.6.1/etsi_nfv_sol001_vnfd_types.yaml [^]
TagsNo tags attached.
Relationships
Attached Files
Issue History
Date ModifiedUsernameFieldChange
25-02-2021 08:34yaoyudieNew Issue
31-01-2022 14:09Vlademir BrusseNote Added: 0016153
31-01-2022 14:10Vlademir BrusseNote Edited: 0016153bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=16153#r579
31-01-2022 14:12Vlademir BrusseNote Added: 0016154
31-01-2022 14:12Vlademir BrusseStatusnew => closed
31-01-2022 14:12Vlademir BrusseAssigned To => Vlademir Brusse
31-01-2022 14:12Vlademir BrusseResolutionopen => fixed
31-01-2022 14:12Vlademir BrusseFixed in Version => SOL005ed241 v2.4.1

Notes
(0016153)
Vlademir Brusse   
31-01-2022 14:09   
(edited on: 31-01-2022 14:10)
The way (lower cases) that the enumerated values were specified in OpenStack and in SOL001 does not imply that the same case conventions should be applied to SOL005/SOL003. The issue described is not a strong argument to change the enumerated values in SOL005/SOL003 to lower cases as there can be other cases like this one in the specs.

Case conventions in SOL002/3/5 are different from those in SOL001 and, in OpenStack. There needs to be mediation.

Changing the case in the NFV-MANO APIs would be NBWC.

The SOL WG have decided to close the issue with no action to take on it.
(0016154)
Vlademir Brusse   
31-01-2022 14:12   
Please, check the previous comment.

SOL WG have decided to close the issue with no action to take on it.