ETSI's Bug Tracker - TST008 - NFVI Compute and Network Metrics Specification
View Issue Details
0007746TST008 - NFVI Compute and Network Metrics Specification[NFV Specifications] Editorialpublic06-02-2018 14:2731-07-2018 09:11
Bruno Chatras 
mortona 
normalminorhave not tried
closedfixed 
 
0.0.6 
0007746: Wrong reference
In Clause 5, TST008 has the following text:
“For one list of NFVI platform descriptors, see clause 5.1 of ETSI GS NFV-INF 003 [i.1].”

However, clause 5.1 in INF003 does not deal with this subject.

We believe the reference should be replaced with either:

Clause 5.2 of ETSI GS NFV-IFA 003
Clause 11.2 of ETSI GS NFV-INF 003
Cmause 8 of ETSI GS NFV-PER 001


No tags attached.
Issue History
06-02-2018 14:27Bruno ChatrasNew Issue
10-02-2018 13:58mortonaNote Added: 0015056
10-02-2018 13:58mortonaAssigned To => mortona
10-02-2018 13:58mortonaStatusnew => assigned
15-02-2018 17:16mortonaNote Edited: 0015056bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=15056#r462
15-02-2018 17:32Bruno ChatrasNote Added: 0015057
15-02-2018 22:47mortonaNote Added: 0015058
31-07-2018 09:09aelkenNote Added: 0015191
31-07-2018 09:09aelkenResolutionopen => fixed
31-07-2018 09:11aelkenNote Added: 0015192
31-07-2018 09:11aelkenStatusassigned => closed
31-07-2018 09:11aelkenFixed in Version => 0.0.6

Notes
(0015056)
mortona   
10-02-2018 13:58   
(edited on: 15-02-2018 17:16)
I'm sorry Bruno, but I believe the Reference to clause 5.1 is correct,
but I now see the problem - I have been looking at "INF" and reading
"IFA" in my mind.

The paragraph in TST008 says:
The measured NFVI resources and the measurement processes shall be completely specified in the dimensions of model numbers, firmware versions, software versions, and any other aspects that influence the results (such as physical location of the components within a datacentre's racks and shelves). For example, the fixed frequency of the physical CPU clock in Hz, which governs the rate that the CPU executes instructions, is one important descriptor of the NFVI. Clock Speed may depend on other CPU settings, such as energy-saving power control. For one list of NFVI platform descriptors, see clause 5.1 of ETSI GS NFV-INF 003 [i.1].

and in *IFA*003, clause 5.1, you will find the intended list of parameters, which includes an item that expands on the CPU example given in the TST-008 text above:

• CPU manufacturer, model, configuration (e.g. speed), stepping level, number of cores, hyper threading (or equivalent) status: enabled or disabled, cache size

It seems that we need to add an Informational reference to IFA003, which was intended.

(0015057)
Bruno Chatras   
15-02-2018 17:32   
If your intent was to reference IFA003 "5.1" is the correct clause indeed. "5.2" is a typo in my message. Yes you do need to add an informative reference to IFA003 in that case but that can wait for the next maintenance round.
(0015058)
mortona   
15-02-2018 22:47   
Proposed resolution is in

https://docbox.etsi.org/ISG/NFV/TST/05-CONTRIBUTIONS/2018//NFVTST(18)000017_TST008_Comment_Resolution.zip [^]
(0015191)
aelken   
31-07-2018 09:09   
Cleanup, issue has been fixed per reference in previous note.
(0015192)
aelken   
31-07-2018 09:11   
see previous note, issue fixed and closed.