ETSI's Bug Tracker - CAM
View Issue Details
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0005609CAMPICSpublic14-07-2010 15:4115-09-2010 16:49
ReporterFrancois FISCHER (FSCOM) 
Assigned ToSebastian Muellers 
PrioritynormalSeveritymajorReproducibilityalways
StatusclosedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product Version 
Target VersionFixed in VersionNext Release 
Summary0005609: doorOpen item
DescriptionThe doorOpen is not applicable to emergency vehicle. But the table A.16 item 28, uses status "o" for emergency vehicle. This should be "x"

Then the condition for public transport vehicle is not correct because belonging to a "dynamic" event: 30s after closing door. PICS shall only refer to static conditions, which can be evaluated when filling the PICS.
Steps To Reproduce
Additional InformationI recommend a complete cross check of this table
TagsNo tags attached.
Relationships
related to 0005614closed user609 missing optional statement for emergency vehicle 
Attached Files
Issue History
Date ModifiedUsernameFieldChange
14-07-2010 15:41Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)New Issue
15-07-2010 15:42Sebastian MuellersStatusnew => assigned
15-07-2010 15:42Sebastian MuellersAssigned To => user67
16-07-2010 11:06Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Relationship addedrelated to 0005614
16-07-2010 11:09Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Note Added: 0009527
16-07-2010 11:13Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Note Added: 0009530
16-07-2010 11:13Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Statusassigned => confirmed
26-07-2010 12:40user67Statusconfirmed => resolved
26-07-2010 12:40user67Fixed in Version => Next Release
26-07-2010 12:40user67Resolutionopen => fixed
26-07-2010 12:40user67Note Added: 0009569
26-07-2010 13:56Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Assigned Touser67 => Sebastian Muellers
26-07-2010 13:56Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Statusresolved => feedback
26-07-2010 13:56Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Resolutionfixed => reopened
26-07-2010 13:56Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)Note Added: 0009571
15-09-2010 16:49Sebastian MuellersStatusfeedback => closed
15-09-2010 16:49Sebastian MuellersNote Added: 0009742
15-09-2010 16:49Sebastian MuellersResolutionreopened => fixed

Notes
(0009527)
Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)   
16-07-2010 11:09   
3 issues to be resolved:
1 - remove all dynamic conditions (only static conditions refering to existing PICS items shall be used)
2 - doorOpen "x" for emergencyVehicle", waiting for mantis 0005614 resolution

3 - crosscheck other PICS items as necessary.
(0009530)
Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)   
16-07-2010 11:13   
OK
(0009569)
user67   
26-07-2010 12:40   
According to mantis 0005614 resolution, the item is now optional for emergency.
Description of an event is static (a state for a state machine for example), apparition of the event is dynamic (the IUT is in state x for example). there is no need to change the condition for public transport.
Complete check of the table done.
(0009571)
Francois FISCHER (FSCOM)   
26-07-2010 13:56   
I disagree with the static/dynamic view in the latest note. Static statement are those concerning configuration for instance. Opening and closing door can never be static. Samme applies for the state machine. States are changing and are then dynamic. I do not see the point with the description. Anyway when filling a PICS you can not evaluate the condition "30s after closing door" because it is even dynamic. Thus this can not be a condition applying to a PICS item status.
(0009742)
Sebastian Muellers   
15-09-2010 16:49   
modifcation mde accordign to our latest understanding of 'situational mandatory'