ETSI's Bug Tracker - GeoNetworking
View Issue Details
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0005604GeoNetworkingBase Specpublic13-07-2010 14:2420-02-2015 14:39
ReporterSebastian Muellers 
Assigned ToAndreas Festag 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityhave not tried
StatusclosedResolutionfixed 
PlatformOSOS Version
Product VersionTS 102 636 4-1 V0.0.6 
Target VersionFixed in VersionNext Release 
Summary0005604: reference to informative spec ETSI TS 102 636-4-2
Descriptionin GEOUNICAST packet handling/Source operations/step7-b it is defined to execute media-dependent procedures. However, the meid dependent procedures are defiend in a spec which is referenced in teh section 'Informative references'. The reference should be moved to the normative section.
Steps To Reproduce
Additional Information
TagsNo tags attached.
Relationships
Attached Files
Issue History
Date ModifiedUsernameFieldChange
13-07-2010 14:24Sebastian MuellersNew Issue
13-07-2010 14:24Sebastian MuellersStatusnew => assigned
13-07-2010 14:24Sebastian MuellersAssigned To => Andreas Festag
30-07-2010 16:46Andreas FestagNote Added: 0009586
30-07-2010 16:47Andreas FestagStatusassigned => confirmed
30-07-2010 16:52Andreas FestagNote Edited: 0009586
30-08-2010 16:57Sebastian MuellersNote Added: 0009656
01-02-2011 05:39Andreas FestagStatusconfirmed => resolved
01-02-2011 05:39Andreas FestagFixed in Version => Next Release
01-02-2011 05:39Andreas FestagResolutionopen => fixed
01-02-2011 05:39Andreas FestagNote Added: 0009987
20-02-2015 14:39Sebastian MuellersNote Added: 0012798
20-02-2015 14:39Sebastian MuellersStatusresolved => closed

Notes
(0009586)
Andreas Festag   
30-07-2010 16:46   
(edited on: 30-07-2010 16:52)
Hmmm. There is one standard for media-independent GeoNetworking and there might be multiple standards for media-dependent GeoNetworking for the individual media (AKA access technologies). So, it is intended to have the media-dependent standards informative because it allows to implement GeoNetworking for a single access technology only. Making media-dependent standards normative would require to implement all of them.

One option could be to make the standard for media-dependent GeoNetworking for ITS-G5A as normative and the others (e.g. infrared, in case these standards will exists one day) as informative. The argumentation would be that every car has to be equipped with ITS G5A and the other media/access technologies are "optional"/"nice to have".

Any comment?
(0009656)
Sebastian Muellers   
30-08-2010 16:57   
If we make the reference normative, then in media-dependent standard we can state something like "at least one of the defined access technologies shall be implemented" (this assumes that each access technology is defined in a sub section of the document)
(0009987)
Andreas Festag   
01-02-2011 05:39   
Moved to normative references
(0012798)
Sebastian Muellers   
20-02-2015 14:39   
start of new project