ETSI's Bug Tracker - SIP Library
View Issue Details
0005257SIP LibraryBug reportpublic24-06-2009 08:5422-09-2010 14:16
Bostjan Pintar 
Bostjan Pintar 
normalminoralways
resolvedfixed 
 
V1.5.0 
0005257: Method value should be present in Dummy templates inside LineRequest
Dummy templates were generated because of easier introduction of new types into SIP protocol. They were not used in ATS level of the project but only for modifications. With this correction this templates can be used also in ATS level of project where is necessary to check if some method were received.

With this correction optimization of code can be done.
No tags attached.
Issue History
24-06-2009 08:54Bostjan PintarNew Issue
24-06-2009 08:54Bostjan PintarStatusnew => assigned
24-06-2009 08:54Bostjan PintarAssigned To => Stephan Schulz
24-06-2009 08:58Bostjan PintarNote Added: 0008791
24-06-2009 09:28Stephan SchulzNote Added: 0008792
24-06-2009 09:32Stephan SchulzAssigned ToStephan Schulz => Bostjan Pintar
24-06-2009 09:32Stephan SchulzStatusassigned => feedback
24-06-2009 14:43Bostjan PintarNote Added: 0008793
22-09-2010 14:16Bostjan PintarStatusfeedback => resolved
22-09-2010 14:16Bostjan PintarFixed in Version => V1.5.0
22-09-2010 14:16Bostjan PintarResolutionopen => fixed
22-09-2010 14:16Bostjan PintarNote Added: 0009765

Notes
(0008791)
Bostjan Pintar   
24-06-2009 08:58   
Corrections should be done only in module LibSip_Templates.
(0008792)
Stephan Schulz   
24-06-2009 09:28   
I would then like to suggest to rename from "dummy" to "message" template or something like this, e.g., m_ACK_Dummy to m_ACK_message.
My understanding of dummy is that it means "useless".

How do you want to however treat mw_requestLine_dummy? Parameterize it with a method?
Also what about the message body setting to omit .. that may no longer we feasible either.

In principle I am ok with this change. But i would like to see a more concrete solution proposal

This means however that this change will affect a number of templates .. but it should anyway at this point be mainly in the SIP libary
(0008793)
Bostjan Pintar   
24-06-2009 14:43   
I would parameterized mw_requestLine_dummy with method. In other modified templates we do not have any need to put method in it. Dummy templates which are prepaired for sending will not be used because parameters need to be set for sending. Because of this reasone we can leave Dummy postfix. Only templates for receiving can be used in case if only method need to be checked. This solution can be done only on LibSipTemplates module. And there will not be any other changes.
(0009765)
Bostjan Pintar   
22-09-2010 14:16   
fixed